Confidence in home insurance masks understanding gap: Paymentshield

Three quarters of adults with home insurance are not confident they understand the concept of underinsurance, Paymentshield reports.

Related topics:  home insurance,  Paymentshield
Lucy Whalen | Editorial Assistant, Protection Reporter
16th November 2026
house hands protection home insurance
"A simple question about underinsurance, changing circumstances or whether someone has reviewed their cover recently can open up a valuable conversation."
- Nasar Hussain - Paymentshield

While over half of UK adults with home insurance initially said they have 'no particular concerns' about their existing policy, there are gaps in understanding and action, new research from Paymentshield has found.

The findings are based on a survey of 2,000 UK adults conducted by Opinium on behalf of Paymentshield in September 2026, which aims to highlight attitudes towards home insurance, awareness of underinsurance and behaviours relating to policy reviews.

Paymentshield says the research reveals several areas where advisers can add value by helping clients better understand their cover and identify potential gaps in protection.

Just one quarter of those with home insurance surveyed said they are confident they understand what 'underinsurance' means: where coverage is insufficient to meet the full cost of rebuilding your property or replacing possessions. 

This follows separate research from RebuildCostASSESSMENT, which estimated that 70% of UK properties are underinsured, potentially leaving homeowners financially exposed in the event of a claim. 

In addition, Paymentshield found that one fifth of respondents said they know their circumstances have changed significantly since they last reviewed their home insurance policy, meaning the value of their contents or property may have also changed. 

25% of respondents who have remortgaged also said that nobody checked to see if their existing home insurance remained suitable at the time.

Following widespread media coverage of wildfires this year, half of UK adults with home insurance have taken no action to check whether they would have the appropriate buildings and/or contents cover if they lost their home.

READ MORE: Shepherds Friendly appoints chief commercial officer and executive director

Overall, one in five home insurance policy holders are not confident they understand what their policy actually covers them for. Misconceptions are also common: 57% of policy holders, for example, would expect accidental damage to be covered as standard, despite this typically requiring additional cover. 

The research also revealed differences in attitudes and confidence levels across generations. While 72% of boomers with home insurance reported having no concerns about their existing policy, this fell to 39% among millennials and 30% of Gen Z. 

68% of Gen Z respondents said they want advice to ensure their home is properly protected, compared with 54% of millennials and 32% of Gen X, and 59% Gen Z respondents would also be willing to pay more for home insurance for peace of mind that they had the right cover, compared with 55% of millennials and 39% of Gen X.

"The biggest risk for many homeowners isn't necessarily having no insurance at all," Nasar Hussain, associate director of intermediated household at Paymentshield, said. "It's believing they have the right cover in place for their needs.

"Homeowners might feel confident that their insurance is doing what they need it to, but our research suggests there can be a significant gap between that initial confidence and their understanding of what they’re actually covered for.

"Underinsurance is a good example. It can have devastating financial consequences, yet three quarters of homeowners aren’t confident they understand what it means. We’re also seeing a lack of action when circumstances change, even though this can affect the level of cover someone needs.

"For advisers, this creates a clear opportunity to add value. Younger homeowners in particular appear to be more open to receiving professional guidance, but conversations around home insurance shouldn’t be limited to any specific age group.

"A simple question about underinsurance, changing circumstances or whether someone has reviewed their cover recently can open up a valuable conversation and help ensure clients have the protection they need."

More like this
Latest from Financial Reporter
Latest from Property Reporter
CLOSE
Subscribe
to our newsletter

Join a community of over 8,000 intermediaries and keep up-to-date with industry news and upcoming events via our newsletter.